Thick VS. Thin Mattresses? Which One Should You Choose?

Looking for a new mattress can be hard, especially when you have so many choices available.

How can you choose the best one? Do you prefer comfort over style?

What makes a mattress comfortable? 

How thick should a mattress be? Or, should it be thin?

There are a number of questions that remain unanswered. However, thinking about all these things before purchasing a mattress is something natural.

After all, a mattress isn’t a light investment. As a matter of fact, a quality mattress by any high-end brand is going to be expensive.

So when you’re spending a significant amount of money on the mattress, it needs to be comfortable.

Needless to say, your mattress plays a vital role in your sleep. Imagine sleeping on a mattress that is uncomfortable, too thin, or lumpy?

I’m certain you don’t want to risk your sleep after a hectic day at work.

Now imagine sleeping on a comfortable, thick, cloud-like mattress after coming home from a long day at work? It feels like nirvana, what do you say?

So what kind of a mattress do you need? A thick mattress? Or, perhaps a thin one?

Let’s see what each one of them brings to the table.

thin vs thick mattresses

For all those in a rush, here I have a rundown of the major differences that you’ll find between a thin and thick mattress. Have a look at the table below:

No. of Characteristics Thin Mattresses Thick Mattresses
Better for kids
Better for adults
Good for light sleepers
Good for heavy sleepers
For back injury
For joint stiffness
High support level
Better body conformity
Economically priced

Thin Mattresses

thin mattress

Most mattresses are usually constructed using 4 to 5 layers of foam or innerspring. However, a mattress that is thin may have a lesser number of foam layers.

Let me be clear, layers of foam and coil system prominently affect how a mattress feels to the touch. 

It is precisely the reason thin mattresses tend to be uncomfortable for some.

Just to make it clear, any mattress that is 6-inch or less in thickness would be known as a thin mattress.

Nevertheless, a thin mattress has both its pros and cons. So here are some of the merits a thin mattress accompanies:

It is excellent for people with a back injury.

It is relatively cheap as compared to a thick mattress.

It is appropriate for kids as well as teens or lightweight individuals.

It is easier to move around and simple to manage.

Now let’s have a look at some of its cons:

It doesn’t work well for heavier individuals.

It may not provide you with adequate support in case it’s too thin.

It wouldn’t contour well to your body.

It may develop lumps if not cared for.

Even then, regardless of all the cons, several people prefer sleeping on a thin mattress. If you’re one of them, I would suggest you check Lucid 5-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress.

Lucid 5-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress
  • Gel memory foam creates a cooler sleep experience than traditional memory
  • Dual-layer technology; 1-inch ventilated; gel memory foam layer with a 4-inch foam base layer to create a firm,...
  • Open cell construction creates more durable, long-lasting memory foam; 10-year warranty

It is certainly the best selling mattress when it comes to thin mattresses. I’m sure it won’t disappoint you.

Thick Mattresses

thick mattress

They say comfort is derived from the materials used in the making of the mattress; however, I don’t agree with it.

I believe the thickness level of your mattress defines how comfortable it would be. Am I wrong?

Okay. Think about coming home, all tired and exhausted. What would be the first thing you’ll want? 

Your bed? Isn’t that right?

Henceforth, your bed needs to be comfortable. The more layers of foam it has, the more comfortable it is going to be. It is as simple as that.

As the layers of foam would increase, the thickness of your mattress would increase as well.

The best part of the story is that most of the luxury hotels these days use thick mattresses as a symbol of extravagance. Thereby, for anyone who enjoys luxury, a thick mattress is essential.

I can say this with experience since I have used both thin and thick mattresses. I am currently using Latex For Less 9-inch Natural Latex Foam Mattress, and I can swear by its comfort.

Lucid 5-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress
  • THE COMFORT DIFFERENCE | 6 inches of 100% natural dunlop latex in firm (85 density), 2 inches of 100% natural talalay...
  • 100% ALL-NATURAL LATEX | Our 100% all-natural latex mattress is a pure, botanical product that is sustainably harvested...
  • TWO (SIDED) FIRMNESS OPTIONS | With its unique 2-in-1 design, the Latex for Less Latex Mattress has both a medium side...

Adding to it, most of the thick high-end mattresses come with a thickness level of 8-12 inches. Mine is 9 inches, but I believe it is sufficient for me.

An additional tip that I would like to share with you is that if you weigh more than 150 pounds, you shouldn’t settle for a mattress less than 12 inches thick. The thicker your mattress would be, the more weight it can bear.

Alright. Like a thin mattress, a thick mattress has its own pros and cons as well. What did you think? I was going to miss them, huh?

Let’s check out its pros first:

It comes with a higher support level.

It conforms well to your body.

It is an excellent choice for people with more body weight.

It is bouncy; henceforth, soft to the touch.

It is great for joint stiffness, sore muscles, and body aches.

It is often more long-lasting than a thin mattress.

Done with the pros, now let’s switch to the cons:

It is relatively more expensive than a thin mattress.

It is difficult to move around.

It may start sagging earlier if not appropriately maintained.

It may heat up due to joint layers and layers of foam. Therefore, it may not be a good fit for warmer regions.

Fair enough? Both kinds have their own ups and downs. Still, if you ask me, I’ll always choose a thick mattress over a thin one.

I prefer sleeping on soft surfaces. It is precisely the reason I never liked flooring all my childhood. 

Funny, eh? My childhood was really weird. Trust me; you don’t want to know about it!

Besides that, I remember reading various online product reviews where couples flatly voted for a thick mattress.

People usually believe a thick mattress has the element of added comfort. What do you say?

Which one are you going to purchase?

Are you still contemplating which one is better?

It is okay to think about it, just be careful and make a rational decision. Give a thorough read to everything I have shared above, and I am confident it is going to help you make an informed decision.

After all, you’re not going to buy a new mattress every other year. Are you? Best of luck, my pals!

Leave a Comment